FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Press Release: MASTIO publishes the 15th Edition Natural Gas Pipeline Report

March 15, 2011


MASTIO recently published the 2011, Fifteenth Edition of the industry wide Natural Gas Pipeline Customer Value / Loyalty Benchmarking Study and is pleased to present its findings.  The study was released to subscribers in early February.  This new study provides results concerning interstate, intrastate and Canadian pipelines.     

The 2011 study is based on interviews with industrials, LDC’s, independent power producers, producers and marketers.  Each respondent rated pipelines on 30 attributes such as: representatives who listen well, effective after hours support, firm gas transportation is highly reliable, timely resolution of problems plus overall company performance and how likely would you be to recommend your pipeline.  The study also asks several open-ended questions.  For example, all respondents are asked “Besides price, what is the most important factor that you use to select one transportation provider over another”.  Respondents are also asked “What was the biggest disappointment you have experienced with each of your pipelines over the last 12 months”.  The most important issues to transporters of natural gas continue not to change much from edition to edition. 

The most important issue to transporters of natural gas in the latest study is firm gas transportation is highly reliable. 

Top 3 Customer Needs

  1. Firm gas transportation is highly reliable.
  2. Communicates in an honest and forth
  3. Scheduled gas volumes are accurate and forthright manner.

Source: MASTIO 2011 Natural Gas Transportation Customer Value Study.

 

 

The study findings are divided into the following 4 groups located on the proceeding pages:  

  • Mega Pipelines
  • Major Pipelines
  • Regional Pipelines
  • Major Organizational Groups         

The criterion MASTIO uses to recognize the best pipelines are:

 

  1. Must have a minimum of 30 ratings within the study.
  2. Determined by the pipelines with the highest overall Customer Value Weighted Quality (Benefit) Score. 

Please note that companies need to meet the above criterions to be considered for the MASTIO award.

 

 

MEGA PIPELINE GROUP

 

The following is an alphabetical listing of the pipelines included in the Mega Pipeline Group. 

 

ANR Pipeline Co.

Panhandle Eastern Pipe Line Co.

Columbia Gas Transmission Corp.

Southern Natural Gas Co.

Dominion Transmission, Inc.

Tennessee Gas Pipeline Co.

El Paso Natural Gas Co.

Texas Eastern Transmission Corp.

Gulf South Pipeline Co.

Texas Gas Transmission

Kinder Morgan Interstate Gas Trans.

TransCanada - Mainline System

NGPL

Williams Gas Pipeline-Northwest

Northern Natural Gas Co.

Williams Gas Pipeline-Transco

 

 

Mega Pipeline Index –  The Mega Pipeline Index consists of pipelines with at least 3,500 miles of transportation pipe and deliveries of at least 1 trillion CF (TCF).

 

The following Mega pipelines met the requirements to receive the Mastio Quality Award.

 

Overall Mega Pipeline Index Winner / Highest Score:


Northern Natural Gas Co.

 

Suppliers Who Exceed the Industry Benchmark:

 

Dominion Transmission, Inc.

Natural Gas Pipeline Co. of America

Northern Natural Gas Co.

Panhandle Eastern Pipe Line Co.

Southern Natural Gas Co.

Tennessee Gas Pipeline Co.

Texas Gas Transmission

Williams Gas Pipeline-Northwest 

Williams Gas Pipeline-Transco

 

MAJOR PIPELINE GROUP

 

The following is an alphabetical listing of the pipelines included in the Major Pipeline Group.

 

ANR Pipeline Co.
CenterPoint Energy Gas Transmission Co.
Colorado Interstate Gas Co.
Columbia Gas Transmission Corp.
Columbia Gulf Transmission Co.
Dominion Transmission, Inc.
El Paso Natural Gas Co.
Florida Gas Transmission Co.
Gulf South Pipeline Co.
Kinder Morgan Interstate Gas Trans.
Natural Gas Pipeline Co. of America
Northern Natural Gas Co.
Panhandle Eastern Pipe Line Co.
Southern Natural Gas Co.
Southern Star Central
Tennessee Gas Pipeline Co.
Texas Eastern Transmission Corp.
Texas Gas Transmission
TransCanada Pipelines - Alberta System
TransCanada Pipelines - Mainline System
Trunkline Gas Co.
Williams Gas Pipeline-Northwest
Williams Gas Pipeline-Transco

 

 

 

Major Pipeline Index - The Major Pipeline Index consists of pipelines with at least 3,500 miles of transportation pipe and serves at least 3 states.

 

The following Major pipelines met the requirements to receive the Mastio Quality Award.

  

Overall Major Pipeline Index Winner / Highest Score: 


Northern Natural Gas Co.

 

Suppliers Who Exceed the Industry Benchmark:

 

Colorado Interstate Gas

Dominion Transmission, Inc.

Natural Gas Pipeline Co. of America

Northern Natural Gas Co.

Panhandle Eastern Pipe Line Co.

Southern Natural Gas Co.

Southern Star Central

Tennessee Gas Pipeline Co.

Texas Gas Transmission

TransCanada Pipelines - Alberta System

Trunkline Gas Co.

Williams Gas Pipeline-Northwest

Williams Gas Pipeline-Transco

REGIONAL PIPELINE GROUP

 

The following is an alphabetical listing of the pipelines included in the Regional Pipeline Group.

 

Algonquin Gas Transmission Co.

Iroquois Gas Transmission System L.P.

Alliance Pipeline Ltd.

Kern River Gas Transmission Co.

ATCO Pipelines

National Fuel Gas Supply Corp.

Atmos Pipeline - Texas

Northern Border Pipeline Co.

BC Pipeline

Questar Pipeline Co.

California Gas Transmission

Rockies Express

Carolina Gas Transmission

Trailblazer Pipeline Co.

CenterPoint Energy-MRT

TransColorado Gas Transmission Co.

Cheyenne Plains Gas Pipeline Co.

Transwestern Pipeline Co.

East Tennessee Natural Gas Co.

Union Gas Ltd.

Enogex, Inc.

Vector Pipeline

Enterprise Texas Pipeline, L.P.

Viking Gas Transmission Co.

Gas Transmission Northwest

Williston Basin Interstate Pipeline Co.

Great Lakes Gas Transmission, Inc.

Wyoming Interstate Co. Ltd.

 

 

Regional Pipeline Index - The Regional Pipeline Index consists of pipelines with less than 3,500 miles of transportation pipe and/or serves less than 3 states.

 

The following Regional pipelines met the requirements to receive the Mastio Quality Award.

 

Overall Regional Pipeline Index Winner / Highest Score: 

 

Kern River Gas Transmission Co.

 

Suppliers Who Exceed the Industry Benchmark:

 

Algonquin Gas Transmission Co.

Carolina Gas Transmission

CenterPoint Energy-MRT

East Tennessee Natural Gas Co.

Great Lakes Gas Transmission, Inc.

Iroquois Gas Transmission System L.P.

Kern River Gas Transmission Co.

Northern Border Pipeline Co.

Union Gas Ltd.

Vector Pipeline

Williston Basin Interstate Pipeline Co.

 

MAJOR ORGANIZATIONAL PIPELINE GROUP

 

The following is an alphabetical listing of the pipelines included in the Major Organization Group.

 

Boardwalk Pipeline Group

Oneok Partners Group

CenterPoint Energy Group

Southern Union Group

El Paso Group

Spectra Energy Group

Kinder Morgan Group

TransCanada Group

MidAmerican Energy Group

Williams Group

NiSource Group

 

 

 

Major Organizational Pipeline Group Index – Includes the pipelines that the parent company owns and operates.

 

 The following pipelines met the requirements to receive the Mastio Quality Award.

 

Overall Major Organizational Pipeline Group Index Winner / Highest Score: 

 

MidAmerican Energy Group

 

Suppliers Who Exceed the Industry Benchmark:

 

Boardwalk Pipeline Group

El Paso Group

MidAmerican Energy Group

Oneok Partners Group

Southern Union Group

Spectra Energy Group

Williams Group

 

  

MASTIO specializes in providing an independent third party perspective for clients who want to truly assess their corporate image, discover their perceived level of customer value, find new customers, understand the strengths and weakness of the competition, and supplement their market intelligence.  Our strength is in helping clients re-think established norms, eliminate internal biases, collect and analyze data and transform market research into actions that achieve superior business results. 

 

For more information, contact MASTIO, 2921 N. Belt Hwy., Suite M-14, St. Joseph, MO 64506.  (Phone) 816-364-6200, (Fax) 816-364-3606 or at khuntsman@mastio.com.

 

 

 

APPENDIX

 

 

Legacy Indexes

 

The following MASTIO Customer Satisfaction Indexes are included for legacy purposes.  MASTIO realizes many companies have relied on these indexes to benchmark their performance over the years.  In light of the migration to Customer Value Analysis from the traditional Customer Satisfaction, we feel the Customer Value Indexes provide a clearer picture of a company’s performance relative to other companies.  The Customer Value Index places a higher level of importance on price than the legacy Customer Satisfaction Index.  Also, please note that awards are presented based on a company’s performance on the CV Index.

 

 

Customer Satisfaction Index

Mega Pipelines

 

Rank

Pipeline

Score

1

Northern Natural Gas Co.

87.18

2

Southern Natural Gas Co.

83.25

3

Williams Gas Pipeline-Northwest

82.98

4

Williams Gas Pipeline-Transco

81.67

5

Dominion Transmission, Inc.

79.79

6

Texas Gas Transmission

79.41

7

Panhandle Eastern Pipe Line Co.

78.50

8

Natural Gas Pipeline Co. of America

78.16

9

Tennessee Gas Pipeline Co.

78.14

10

Texas Eastern Transmission Corp.

77.98

11

Gulf South Pipeline Co.

77.91

12

El Paso Natural Gas Co.

76.92

13

ANR Pipeline Co.

75.63

14

TransCanada Pipelines - Mainline System

72.68

15

Kinder Morgan Interstate Gas Trans.

69.90

16

Columbia Gas Transmission Corp.

62.05

 

The Mega Pipeline Index consists of pipelines with at least 3,500 miles of transportation pipe, serves at least 3 states, and deliveries of at least 1 trillion CF (TCF). 

Source:  MASTIO 15th Edition Natural Gas Transportation Customer Value Study – 2011




Legacy Indexes

 

 

Customer Satisfaction Index

Major Pipelines

(Formerly the Long Haul Pipelines)

 

Rank

Pipeline

Score

1

Northern Natural Gas Co.

87.18

2

Southern Star Central

86.26

3

Southern Natural Gas Co.

83.25

4

Williams Gas Pipeline-Northwest

82.98

5

Williams Gas Pipeline-Transco

81.67

6

Trunkline Gas Co.

81.09

7

Dominion Transmission, Inc.

79.79

8

TransCanada Pipelines - Alberta System

79.60

9

Texas Gas Transmission

79.41

10

Colorado Interstate Gas Co.

78.57

11

Panhandle Eastern Pipe Line Co.

78.50

12

Natural Gas Pipeline Co. of America

78.16

13

Tennessee Gas Pipeline Co.

78.14

14

Texas Eastern Transmission Corp.

77.98

15

Gulf South Pipeline Co.

77.91

16

Florida Gas Transmission Co.

77.54

17

El Paso Natural Gas Co.

76.92

18

ANR Pipeline Co.

75.63

19

CenterPoint Energy Gas Transmission Co.

75.08

20

TransCanada Pipelines - Mainline System

72.68

21

Kinder Morgan Interstate Gas Trans.

69.90

22

Columbia Gulf Transmission Co.

65.59

23

Columbia Gas Transmission Corp.

62.05

 

The Major Pipeline Index consists of pipelines with at least 3,500 miles of transportation pipe and serves at least 3 states. 

Source:  MASTIO 15th Edition Natural Gas Transportation Customer Value Study – 2011

 



Legacy Indexes

 

 

 

Customer Satisfaction Index

Regional Pipelines

(Formerly the Short Haul Pipelines)

 

Rank

Pipeline

Score

 

Rank

Pipeline

Score

1

Kern River Gas Transmission

87.60

 

18

ONEOK Gas Transportation Co.

77.75

2

CenterPoint Energy-MRT

84.07

 

19

Transwestern Pipeline Co.

77.24

3

California Gas Transmission

83.99

 

20

TransCanada Pipelines - BC System

76.55

4

Carolina Gas Transmission

82.73

 

21

Wyoming Interstate Co. Ltd.

76.24

5

Northern Border Pipeline Co.

81.84

 

22

Atmos Pipeline - Texas

76.11

6

Viking Gas Transmission Co.

81.16

 

23

BC Pipeline

75.44

7

Union Gas Ltd.

80.75

 

24

Enogex, Inc.

75.35

8

Iroquois Gas Transmission System

79.66

 

25

Cheyenne Plains Gas Pipeline

74.58

9

Questar Pipeline Co.

79.31

 

26

Trailblazer Pipeline Co.

74.22

10

Williston Basin Interstate Pipeline

78.99

 

27

National Fuel Gas Supply Corp.

73.46

11

Midcontinent Express Pipeline

78.53

 

28

Houston Pipe Line Co.

73.08

12

Gas Transmission Northwest

78.53

 

29

Alliance Pipeline Ltd.

71.71

13

Great Lakes Gas Transmission

78.51

 

30

TransColorado Gas Transmission

70.43

14

East Tennessee Natural Gas Co.

78.24

 

31

Southern California Gas Co.

68.93

15

Midwestern Gas Transmission

78.23

 

32

Enterprise Texas Pipeline, L.P.

67.86

16

Algonquin Gas Transmission

77.81

 

33

Rockies Express Pipeline

65.83

17

Vector Pipeline

77.77

 

34

Millennium Pipeline

58.39

 

The Regional Pipeline Index consists of pipelines with less than 3,500 miles of transportation pipe or serves less than 3 states. 

Source:  MASTIO 15th Edition Natural Gas Transportation Customer Value Study – 2011

 

 

 


Legacy Indexes

 

 

Customer Satisfaction Index

Interstate Pipelines

 

Rank

Pipeline

Score

 

Rank

Pipeline

Score

1

Kern River Gas Transmission

87.60

 

23

Midwestern Gas Transmission

78.23

2

Northern Natural Gas Co.

87.18

 

24

Natural Gas Pipeline Co. of America

78.16

3

Southern Star Central

86.26

 

25

Tennessee Gas Pipeline Co.

78.14

4

CenterPoint Energy-MRT

84.07

 

26

Texas Eastern Transmission

77.98

5

Southern Natural Gas Co.

83.25

 

27

Gulf South Pipeline Co.

77.91

6

Williams Gas Pipeline-Northwest

82.98

 

28

Algonquin Gas Transmission

77.81

7

Carolina Gas Transmission

82.73

 

29

Vector Pipeline

77.77

8

Northern Border Pipeline Co.

81.84

 

30

Florida Gas Transmission Co.

77.54

9

Williams Gas Pipeline-Transco

81.67

 

31

Transwestern Pipeline Co.

77.24

10

Viking Gas Transmission Co.

81.16

 

32

El Paso Natural Gas Co.

76.92

11

Trunkline Gas Co.

81.09

 

33

Wyoming Interstate Co. Ltd.

76.24

12

Dominion Transmission, Inc.

79.79

 

34

ANR Pipeline Co.

75.63

13

Iroquois Gas Transmission System L.P.

79.66

 

35

CenterPoint Energy Gas Transmission Co.

75.08

14

Texas Gas Transmission

79.41

 

36

Cheyenne Plains Gas Pipeline

74.58

15

Questar Pipeline Co.

79.31

 

37

Trailblazer Pipeline Co.

74.22

16

Williston Basin Interstate Pipeline Co.

78.99

 

38

National Fuel Gas Supply Corp.

73.46

17

Colorado Interstate Gas Co.

78.57

 

39

TransColorado Gas Transmission Co.

70.43

18

Gas Transmission Northwest

78.53

 

40

Kinder Morgan Interstate Gas Trans.

69.90

19

Midcontinent Express Pipeline

78.53

 

41

Rockies Express Pipeline

65.83

20

Great Lakes Gas Transmission

78.51

 

42

Columbia Gulf Transmission Co.

65.59

21

Panhandle Eastern Pipe Line Co.

78.50

 

43

Columbia Gas Transmission

62.05

22

East Tennessee Natural Gas Co.

78.24

 

 

 

 

 

Source:  MASTIO 15th Edition Natural Gas Transportation Customer Value Study – 2011




Legacy Indexes

 

 

 

 

Customer Satisfaction Index

Canadian Pipelines

 

Rank

Pipeline

Score

1

Union Gas Ltd.

80.75

2

TransCanada Pipelines - Alberta System

79.60

3

TransCanada Pipelines - BC System

76.55

4

BC Pipeline

75.44

5

TransCanada Pipelines - Mainline System

72.68

6

Alliance Pipeline Ltd.

71.71

 

 

 

 

 

Customer Satisfaction Index

Intrastate Pipelines

 

Rank

Pipeline

Score

1

California Gas Transmission

83.99

2

ONEOK Gas Transportation Co.

77.75

3

Atmos Pipeline - Texas

76.11

4

Enogex, Inc.

75.35

5

Houston Pipe Line Co.

73.08

 

 

Source:  MASTIO 15th Edition Natural Gas Transportation Customer Value Study – 2011



 

Legacy Indexes

 

Customer Satisfaction Index

Major Organizational Groups

Rank

Pipeline

Score

1

MidAmerican Energy Group

87.34

2

Williams Group

82.10

3

Southern Union Group

79.19

4

Oneok Partners Group

79.17

5

Boardwalk Pipeline Group

78.94

6

El Paso Group

78.87

7

Spectra Energy Group

78.15

8

CenterPoint Energy Group

78.01

9

TransCanada Group

77.35

10

Kinder Morgan Group

74.52

11

NiSource Group

63.32

 

 

The Major Organizational Groups Index consists of organizational scores compiled from the combined scores of their transportation subsidiaries. 

 

The following table lists the entities that comprise the Major Organizational Groups Index.  Please note that some pipelines may have been sold since the beginning of our research.

 

 

Subsidiaries

Boardwalk Pipeline Group

Gulf South Pipeline

Texas Gas Transmission

 

CenterPoint Energy

CenterPoint Energy-MRT

CenterPoint Energy Gas Transmission Co.

 

El Paso Group

Colorado Interstate Gas Co.

El Paso Natural Gas Co.

Southern Natural Gas Co.

Tennessee Gas Pipeline Co.

Wyoming Interstate Co.

 

Kinder Morgan Group

Kinder Morgan Interstate Gas Trans.

Midcontinent Express Pipeline

Natural Gas Pipeline Co. of America

Rockies Express Pipeline

Trailblazer Pipeline Co.

TransColorado Gas Transmission Co.

MidAmerican Energy Group

Kern River Gas Transmission.

Northern Natural Gas Co.

 

NiSource Group

Columbia Gas Transmission

Columbia Gulf Transmission

 

Oneok Partners Group

Midwestern Gas Transmission

Oneok Gas Transportation

Viking Gas Transmission

 

Southern Union Group

Florida Gas Transmission

Panhandle Eastern Pipe Line

Transwestern Pipeline Co.

Trunkline Gas Co.

 

 

Spectra Energy Group

Algonquin Gas Transmission Co.

BC Pipeline

East Tennessee Natural Gas Co.

Texas Eastern Transmission

Union Gas Ltd.

 

TransCanada Group

ANR Pipeline Co.

Gas Transmission Northwest

Great Lakes Gas Transmission

Northern Border Pipeline

TransCanada Pipelines - Alberta System

TransCanada Pipelines - B.C.  System

TransCanada Pipelines - Mainline System

 

 

Williams Group

Williams Gas Pipeline-Northwest

Williams Gas Pipeline-Transco

 

 

Source:  Mastio 15th Edition Natural Gas Transportation Customer Value Study - 2011

 

This release is provided for editorial use only.  No advertising or other promotional use can be made of this information or of other MASTIO study results without the express prior written consent of MASTIO.